DISCRIMINATION IN EMPLOYMENT ON THE
BASIS OF CRIMINAL RECORD


Click here to access:


Submission No. 19 - Michael Woods


I am concerned about the discrimination facing people who have been subject to an A.V.O. We recently wished to hire an Aboriginal man to cover for one of our employees who had gone on leave for 4 weeks.

However, the man we found - a perfect replacement - was unable to be hired as he was on a "prohibited persons" list. The job primarily involved working with Aboriginal men and boys at risk of self-harm, and despite his potential for our service he is classified as a "risk".

This was largely as a result of an AVO from his former wife. He (our potential employee) claims there he had not been violent, or even threatened violence, but rather that his "ex" had used this legal means to harass him. He said he had agreed to the AVO as it seemed easier just to go along with it rather than attend court, find a solicitor and try to fight what would have been simply his word against hers. He was unaware that he could be placed on this list and unable to obtain employment in certain jobs as a result of this.

It does seem that the "prohibited persons" list has gone a step too far in its intent to protect the community, and actually can be an additional form of punishment over and above any court findings. Perhaps some greater level of distinction is needed as to when a person is really a threat.

In taking this one step further, I suggest that the "prohibited persons" list is likely to inadvertently discriminate against Aboriginal people in some cases. This is as a result of the increased likelihood of an Aboriginal person being charged and convicted for crimes of "violence" - especially the old trifecta of "offensive language, resisting arrest and assaulting a police officer". While there is a process to have one's name removed from the list, it is not easy, and mitigates against the part of employment in helping to incorporate convicted people back into the community.

 

© Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission. Last updated 20 April 2005.
Your comments and feedback are welcome. Email us at: webfeedback@humanrights.gov.au